Who Can Prepare Your Small Business Taxes

CPA working with businesswoman compiling tax records
••• whyframestudio / Getty Images

You have your small business tax information in order, and now it's time to find a tax preparer. Who is the best person to help you prepare your tax return? Although business tax returns can be prepared by a number of different types of skilled accounting professionals, some are better than others  

All Individuals who are paid to prepare tax returns MUST have a Preparer Tax ID Number (PTIN), provided by the IRS. At this point, no exam is necessary to receive a PTIN, but in future paid tax preparers will be required to pass a qualifying exam and background check. If you pay someone to do your business and personal taxes, ask to see the person's PTIN identifier.

Reasons to Not Prepare Your Own Business Tax Returns

You can certainly prepare your own business tax return. In fact, anyone can prepare a tax return for someone else; you or your brother-in-law can prepare your tax return using online tax software. Here are three reasons why this isn't a good idea: 

You Don't Know What You Don't Know

Even with tax software, you may miss critical pieces of information that could negatively affect your tax return. While the tax software companies ask a lot of questions to get you the best savings, they are a one-size-fits-all operation. They may not ask the right question for your specific business situation. 

Business Returns Are More Complicated Than Personal Returns

Each business is unique, and you need an experienced business tax preparer to make sure you are filing your return correctly. 

A Tax Software Company Won't Help You Later

If your business tax return gets audited by the IRS, having a tax preparer who will help you is a major benefit. 

What a Tax Preparer Does

A good tax preparer fulfills several roles. The preparer can serve as a tax advisor, helping you make tax planning decisions throughout the business year. They may be able to provide tips that will keep you better organized with the tax information you collect.

Of course, the preparer can also prepare the tax return for you. This individual should sign the return, so it is clear who did the work. As mentioned earlier, check that your preparer has the necessary training and ask to see their Preparer Tax ID Number (PTIN).

Also, your tax preparer should be able to help if you get audited, by representing you before the IRS and Tax Court. Not all tax preparers can do this. Certainly, you can hire someone after the fact to represent you with the IRS if you get audited, but it's always better to have the person who completed the tax return be present at the audit to explain what was done and why.

The Types of Professional Tax Preparers

You can have your business taxes prepared by an unenrolled preparer, but this person cannot sign your tax return or represent you before the IRS for an audit.

An accountant also may be able to prepare and sign tax returns, but the designation of "accountant" does not provide assurance of certification, nor does it give the accountant the ability to represent you before the IRS, even if this person has signed your tax return. Accountants are classified by the IRS as "unenrolled preparers."

An Enrolled Agent is also able to prepare tax returns. An enrolled agent is an individual who has been given the privilege of practicing before the Internal Revenue Service (IRS), which includes preparing and filing documents, communicating with the IRS, and representing taxpayers in matters involving the IRS, including tax audits. But an Enrolled Agent cannot represent you in Tax Court.

A Certified Public Accountant (CPA) is an accounting professional who has passed a qualifying exam and who is licensed to provide accounting and tax services to individuals and businesses. Most CPA's specialize, so find a CPA who does mostly taxes if you want a CPA to provide tax preparation and advisory services.

You Are Ultimately Responsible

No matter who prepares your business taxes, you (the business owner, are ultimately responsible for the accuracy and completeness of the tax return. Errors and omissions will cost you in fines and penalties, and you can't turn to your tax preparer and ask for the money.

Tips for Selecting a Tax Preparer

Before you hire a tax preparer, check credentials. Ask for the PTIN and any licenses (such as a CPA license). Make sure the license is current. Tax preparers (CPAs and Enrolled Agents, for example) are required to take continuing education courses each year in order to keep their licenses.

A tax preparer who has not taken these courses does not have a legitimate right to sign tax returns. ​The IRS has some additional suggestions for selecting a tax preparer.