Best Livestock Insurance

American Family Insurance offers the best livestock insurance

We publish unbiased reviews; our opinions are our own and are not influenced by payments from advertisers. Learn about our independent review process and partners in our advertiser disclosure.

Livestock insurance is a type of specialty insurance product designed to protect livestock from the unexpected. Farmers and ranchers obtain policies to cover their livestock during transit, from mortality, as well as to protect them during losses and even theft. Some policies also protect farmers from potential loss of income related to their livestock. 

The best livestock insurance is found through insurance providers that know the livestock industry, have easily accessible customer service agents, and offer competitive quotes with affordable premiums. Additionally, the companies provide multiple types of policies, offer discounts, and cover various perils that may be encountered. These are our top selections for livestock insurance.

Best Livestock Insurance of 2021

Best Overall : American Family Insurance


American Family

American Family

  • Average Cost: Not disclosed
  • No. of Coverage Options: 6
  • Coverage Limit: Varies
Why We Chose It

American Family Insurance has almost a century of experience and covers many different types of livestock, plus insurance agents can be reached 24/7. 

Pros & Cons
Pros
  • Covers more types of animals than most companies

  • Offer farm and ranch resources

Cons
  • Much purchase add ons for other coverage

  • Need to contact agents for a quote

Overview

American Family Insurance was founded in 1927 as Farmers Mutual Automobile Insurance in Madison, Wisconsin. It covers more types of animals than most insurance companies, including exotic animals such as elk, bison, emus, and ostriches. It also covers multiple natural disasters like sinkholes, volcanic eruptions, lightning, wind, hail, and flooding. You can purchase an earthquake add-on as well and an animal perils endorsement that covers things like accidental shooting, drowning, attack by dogs, attack by wild animals, and building collapse. 

Overall, the company covers more types of livestock and perils than most of its competitors, has a well-organized website, and boasts a long industry track record of success. You can get coverage limits and prices by contacting an agent through online chat or over the phone and you can file a claim online anytime through the claims number or with your assigned agent.

Best for Custom Policies : AXA XL


AXA XL

 AXA XL

  • Average Cost: Not disclosed
  • No. of Coverage Options: Numerous custom options
  • Coverage Limit: $30 million per farm
Why We Chose It

AXA XL offers flexible and individually tailored livestock coverage. It also provides risk consulting and training sessions. 

Pros & Cons
Pros
  • Offers worldwide coverage

  • Covers all classes of livestock

Cons
  • Tailored more to larger companies

  • Outdated website

Overview

AXA XL was founded in 1986 and merged into its current company in 2019. It offers specialty insurance policies, including livestock, equine, marine cargo, aquaculture, art, political risk, and entertainment insurance policies. In addition, it provides risk consulting services and bespoke product design. 

AXA XL works with large public companies, private companies, and farms with locations around the world. It has an in-house claims process and brokers to help decide which policy is best for you and then tailor it to fit your needs. The policies can be customized based on your farm’s size, location, and types of animals, and more. You can call a local broker or set up an appointment online and initiate a claim over the phone or through email.

While coverage costs and limits vary, AXA XL usually covers a farm up to $30 million. A typical livestock policy will cover mortality, infertility, theft, and disease. The products are designed by professionals, including vets, to provide adequate coverage. All livestock classes including production animals, exotics, and embryos and semen are covered on your property as well as in transit.

Best for Equine Coverage : Allen Financial Insurance Group


Allen Financial Insurance Group

 Allen Financial Insurance Group

  • Average Cost: $7,500+
  • No. of Coverage Options: 4
  • Coverage Limit: $10 million
Why We Chose It

Allen Financial Insurance Group offers multiple types of specialty policies tailored for equine owners as well as other livestock and farm policies and you can apply for a quote online.

Pros & Cons
Pros
  • Wide variety of specialty insurance products

  • Offers details about each type of coverage

Cons
  • Outdated website

  • Company not as well known as others

Overview

The Equestrian Group is a division of Allen Financial Insurance Group that offers specialty equine policies including equestrian business policies, rodeo insurance, high valued horse policies, transit, and equestrian show coverage. The company also offers coverage for alpacas, llamas, poultry, cattle, and more livestock as well as agritourism, agritainment, equipment breakdown, and numerous other specialty products and services. 

Allen Financial Insurance Group has a long history in the specialty insurance business and it works with partners to underwrite complex insurance policies for specialized industries. You can get a quote online or over the phone and make payments online. Customer service can be reached via email or over the phone and you need to contact an agent to initiate the claims process. 

Allen Financial Insurance Group’s website also offers blogs and industry news and resources. Equine coverage is typically limited to $10 million per farm and $1 million per animal. Policies cover the horses and can also be purchased for instructors, trainers, owners, and equestrian clubs.

Best for Variety of Covered Perils : Shelter Insurance


Shelter Insurance

Shelter Insurance

  • Average Cost: Not disclosed
  • No. of Coverage Options: 5
  • Coverage Limit: Varies
Why We Chose It

Shelter’s livestock insurance policies provide comprehensive coverage and offer protection against a wide variety of perils. 

Pros & Cons
Pros
  • Offers multiple farm insurance discounts

  • Multiple policies to choose from

Cons
  • Only operate in 15 states

  • Customer service only available during business hours

Overview

Shelter Insurance was founded in 1946 as The MFA Mutual Insurance Company and sells homeowners, auto, life, and farm insurance, as well as livestock, and equipment insurance. Its livestock insurance policies cover the usual perils such as fire, accidents, thefts, and floods, but it also covers other less common perils including explosions, volcanic eruptions, chemical spills, falling objects, and more. 

Shelter Insurance offers a comprehensive farm insurance policy as well as individual policies. The individual policies you can choose from are livestock insurance, farm equipment coverage, farm property, and liability-only policies. You need to speak to a customer service agent to get a quote and maximum coverage information. 

Shelter Insurance also offers several farm owners discounts including discounts for new homes, mobile homes, protective devices, and heating systems. You can pay your bill and file a claim online from your account. 

Best for Transit Coverage : The Hartford


The Hartford

The Hartford

  • Average Cost: Not disclosed
  • No. of Coverage Options: 9
  • Coverage Limit: Varies
Why We Chose It

The Hartford offers a century of insurance experience and has a full livestock transit policy with coverage for things like carcass removal and substitution of vehicles. 

Pros & Cons
Pros
  • Multiple livestock insurance options including transit coverage

  • Local underwriters and 24/7 claims processing

Cons
  • Need to call agent for a quote

  • Number of coverage choices may be overwhelming

Overview

The Hartford has over a century of insurance industry experience. It was founded in 1810 as a company that offered fire insurance. It has since branched out to offer multiple types of insurance including livestock, auto, home, employee benefits, as well as financial products and services. Since 1916, the company has offered specialized livestock, equine, and animal mortality insurance to livestock owners and businesses.

The Hartford has multiple types of livestock transit insurance to choose from as well as horse insurance, high-value animal insurance, swine, poultry, and hatchery insurance, and more. You'll need to speak to a local livestock agent for a quote and to find out more about coverage limits and specifications. However, you can file a claim online or over the phone anytime. 

Livestock policies cover horses, hogs, poultry, hatcheries, cattle, police and service dogs, and more. They can be customized and are designed to cover commercial livestock and high-value animals while located on-premises or in transit. Some transit policy options include carcass removal, substitution of vehicles, coverage after transit, deck collapse coverage, and refusal of shipment coverage. 

Best for Whole Farm Coverage : Nationwide


Nationwide

Nationwide

  • Average Cost: Not disclosed
  • No. of Coverage Options: 3
  • Coverage Limit: Varies
Why We Chose It

Nationwide offers whole farm insurance policies that you can customize and tailor to meet your needs. It has multiple insurance products to choose from as well as add ons. 

Pros & Cons
Pros
  • Transparent coverage options

  • Customizable farm policies

Cons
  • Need to contact an agent for pricing details

  • Livestock that die from disease aren’t covered

Overview

Founded in Columbus, Ohio in 1926, Nationwide began by selling automobile insurance to local farmers in Ohio. It later branched out to farmers in several other states and then also began selling fire and life insurance. Its headquarters are still located in Ohio, but it also has offices in all 50 states and offers insurance nationwide as the name suggests. 

Nationwide offers three different comprehensive whole-farm policies for your farm and ranch which you can customize with add ons. When you select an Agrichoice farm insurance policy, you also get livestock coverage for your sheep, cows, bulls, swine, goats, and lambs. 

Nationwide’s broad loss of protection generally covers floods, accidental shootings, earthquakes, and more. You can insure your livestock individually, as a blanket policy, or as a herd, which affects the maximum amount of available coverage. 

Some optional coverage options include insurance for your ATVs and tractors, sewer pump backup, and disruption of farming operations. For pricing details, to apply, and to get a quote, you'll need to speak to a farm agent. Claims can be filed and tracked online and you can also pay your bills online.

Final Verdict

Overall, we recommend checking out American Family Insurance. The company has positive overall reviews, a strong financial rating, and offers livestock and farm and ranch policies with many add ons to choose from. 

Compare the Best Livestock Insurance

Company AM Best Rating Avg. Annual Premium Coverage Limit Other Farm Policies
American Family Insurance Best Overall A Contact agent Varies Farm and ranch, tractor equipment, agribusiness
AXA XL Best for Custom Policies A+  Contact agent  $30 million per farm Equine, aquaculture, marine, livestock
Allen Financial Insurance Group Best for Equine Coverage Not rated  $7,500+  $10 million per farm Trainers, stables, riding clubs, farm events 
Shelter Insurance Best for Variety of Covered Perils  Contact agent  Varies  Farm property, equipment, liability, livestock 
The Hartford Best for Transit Coverage  A+  Contact agent  Varies  Poultry, swine, hatchery, marine 
Nationwide Best for Whole Farm Coverage  A+  Contact agent  Varies Home, farm, ranch, truck 

How to Choose the Best Livestock Insurance

The first step in choosing livestock insurance is to go with a company with a strong reputation and extensive livestock experience. Make sure they offer coverage for the type of livestock you own and offer additional add-on coverage for unique situations.

It's also important to check the ratings and reviews of each insurance and compare their quotes to ensure you're getting the most coverage for your money. Finally, confirm the type of customer service offered so you can make any claims and get reimbursed hassle-free.

Frequently Asked Questions

What Does Livestock Insurance Cover?

Livestock insurance typically covers livestock from injury and death due to things like theft, accidents, and natural perils including storms, hurricanes, and floods. Some policies also cover property damage and car accidents that your livestock may have caused as well as loss of income due to your livestock being injured, contracting a disease or virus, or dying. 

Farms and ranches can be expensive and include farm loans that need to be repaid, expensive inventory, and valuable livestock, so it’s important to have a livestock insurance policy to protect your livelihood.  

Is Livestock Insurance the Same as Farm and Ranch Insurance?

A typical farm and ranch insurance policy may cover some of your livestock in certain situations but isn’t designed to cover them in most circumstances. For instance, it doesn’t cover them if they are injured or killed in transit, destroy someone else’s property, or any loss of income if they’re injured or killed. Livestock Insurance will. 

A farm and ranch policy is designed to protect the farm or ranch property as well as includes a liability policy. You may be able to add livestock insurance to your existing policy or you may need to buy a separate policy based on the carrier’s options and your coverage needs. 

What Types of Animals Are Protected by Livestock Insurance?

Typically, livestock insurance policies cover cows, swine, sheep, bulls, goats, and lamb. There is usually a separate policy that covers horses and separate coverage may also be available for alpacas and llamas. It’s important to speak with your insurance agent and thoroughly read your policy documents so you know which animals are covered and which are not. 

Who Should Consider Buying Livestock Insurance?

Consider buying livestock insurance if:

  • You’re involved in the agriculture industry 
  • You own a ranch or farm with livestock
  • Your livestock is your livelihood
  • You transport livestock
  • You’re involved in the equine industry
  • You’re a cattle farmer or rancher
  • You are a small farming operation
  • You’re part of a large conglomerate of farm companies 

Methodology

To find the best livestock insurance, we first created a list of the top 10 providers. Next, we closely evaluated each company based on several factors, including the policies they offer and the types of animals and perils that are covered. Finally, we gave each provider a category based on its specialty. All of the companies on our list are reputable, have strong industry experience, and provide protection for your livestock.